What could Ms. Jones do to enhance her praise to Toby's essay?

Providing a specific example of what made Toby's essay commendable enhances the praise by offering concrete feedback that he can understand and appreciate. When Ms. Jones points out particular strengths, such as a strong argument, effective use of evidence, or a compelling conclusion, Toby gains clarity on what he did well. This not only reinforces positive behaviors but also motivates him to continue writing effectively in the future. Specific praise also allows Toby to see exactly what aspects of his work can be recognized and built upon, which is pivotal for his growth as a writer. Recognizing the nuances of his effort makes the feedback more constructive and impactful for his development.